Conerly Award
- 2007 - Damion Fletcher - RB, University of Southern Mississippi
- 2006 - Patrick Willis - LB/OM, University of MS; No Presenter (Live TV)
- 2005 - Jerious Norwood - RB, Mississippi State University; No Presenter (Live TV)
- 2004 - Michael Boley - LB, University of Southern Mississippi; No Presenter (Live TV)
- 2003 - Eli Manning - Quarterback, University of MS; Presented by Spencer Tillman
- 2002 - Rod Davis - Linebacker, University of Southern MS; Presented by Danny White
- 2001 - Eli Manning - Quarterback, University of MS; Presented by Bart Starr
- 2000 - Josh Bright - Quarterback, Delta State University; Presented by Frank Gifford
- 1999 - Deuce McAllister - Running Back, University of MS; Presented by Pat Summerall
- 1998 - James Johnson - Running Back, MS State University; Presented by Tom Landry
- 1997 - Stewart Patridge - Quarterback, University of MS; Presented by Frank Gifford
- 1996 - Tregnel Thomas - Running Back, Delta State University; Presented by Jack Kemp
Howell Award
- 2007 - Trey Johnson - Jackson State University
- 2006 - Jasper Johnson - Delta State University
- 2005 - Lawrence Roberts - Mississippi State University
Ferris Award
- 2007 - Ed Easley - Catcher, Mississippi State University
- 2006 - Thomas Berkery - IF, Mississippi State University
- 2005 - Brian Pettway - OF, University of Mississippi
- 2004 - Stephen Head - IF/P, University of Mississippi
